Renovating the House or Dividing Its Rooms?

A gentleman considers renovating his house, drawing parallels to Pakistan’s debate on creating new provinces and administrative restructuring.

Imran Naseer Kakazai

A gentleman was contemplating the renovation of his house. The number of rooms was insufficient. Most members of the household were poorly resourced and inadequately trained, while social, political, economic, and administrative problems had accumulated into a persistent burden. Amid these circumstances, the house’s watchman came up with an intriguing suggestion.

“Sir, why not renovate the house? Reduce the size of some rooms, partition the larger ones, and create more rooms altogether. This way, the number of rooms will increase, and everyone will have a separate space.”

The gentleman looked puzzled and asked, “But if we reduce the size of the rooms, what will happen to the comfort, capacity, and quality of accommodation for those living in the house?”

The watchman, with remarkable confidence, replied, “Sir, you should focus on the numbers. Quality can be taken care of later!”

At first glance, this appears to be an ordinary domestic conversation. Yet, viewed against the ongoing debate in Pakistan over the creation of new provinces and the division of existing ones, this simple analogy carries considerable political, administrative, and constitutional significance.

The debate over increasing the number of provinces, restructuring administrative units, and devolving authority to lower tiers of governance is not new. Advocates of new provinces frequently invoke administrative convenience, improved public access, local representation, equitable distribution of resources, and better governance. However, linguistic, historical, cultural, economic, and political complexities make the issue far more consequential than merely drawing new lines on a map.

The question, therefore, is not how many provinces Pakistan should have; the more fundamental question is: What purpose are new provinces expected to serve?

Are we genuinely seeking to resolve administrative shortcomings or merely increase the number of administrative units? Is the objective to facilitate access to public offices, improve education, healthcare, employment, justice and essential services, or will the establishment of new capitals, assemblies, ministries and administrative buildings itself be regarded as an achievement?

If a large province is divided into smaller provinces, yet the administrative culture remains unchanged, authority continues to be concentrated in a few hands, local governments remain ineffective, financial resources are distributed inequitably, and ordinary citizens continue to struggle for the resolution of their basic problems, what tangible benefits would such a division deliver?

Changing the name of a province, its capital, or its geographical boundaries does not automatically improve the quality of governance.

Any proposal for provincial restructuring must therefore be examined in the context of population, geographical size and administrative accessibility, alongside economic viability, fiscal capacity, natural resources, water distribution, infrastructure, employment opportunities and its implications for the federal financial system. The creation of a new province is not merely a political or geographical exercise; it requires comprehensive administrative, financial, and constitutional planning.

Pakistan’s Constitution provides a specific procedure for altering provincial boundaries. Article 239(4) requires the constitutionally prescribed parliamentary process and the approval of the relevant provincial assembly by a two-thirds majority of its total membership where an amendment alters the limits of a province. Consequently, provincial restructuring can not be accomplished merely through political rhetoric or an administrative directive.

Another important question must not be overlooked: Have the existing provinces fulfilled their constitutional obligations under Article 140-A by empowering local governments with meaningful political, administrative, and financial authority? If public problems are addressed through effective local governance, many administrative deficiencies may be remedied without necessarily redrawing provincial boundaries.

Certainly, the case for creating new provinces may rest on legitimate administrative and public-interest considerations. Equally, the financial, constitutional, and administrative costs of such restructuring deserve scrutiny. Both sides of the debate should be assessed through evidence, reliable data, institutional capacity, and the interests of the people rather than political sentiment alone.

We must determine whether Pakistan needs more provinces, stronger and more empowered local governments, improved financial management, or a coherent combination of all three.

Returning to the watchman’s advice, dividing rooms into smaller compartments may increase their number on paper. But if the foundations, roof, water supply, electricity, ventilation, and the actual needs of the occupants are neglected, the house may become more congested and less comfortable despite having more rooms.

In my view, a country is much like a house. Its provinces are administrative rooms, but their worth is not measured by their number. It is determined by the prosperity, security, equal opportunities, dignity, and fundamental rights of the citizens who inhabit them.

The measure of state development is not the number of administrative units created, but the improvement brought into the lives of its citizens.

Pakistan, therefore, needs more than a renovation of its administrative map. It needs a comprehensive institutional reconstruction that improves governance, financial discipline, local autonomy, accountability, and the delivery of public services.

Without these priorities, the watchman’s advice may indeed increase the number of rooms while making the house even more difficult to inhabit. New provinces, too, may become merely new centres of concentrated power rather than instruments of public empowerment.

The real imperative is not simply to create more provinces but to establish a system of governance in which power, authority, resources, and responsibility reach the ordinary citizen.

A house is not made more habitable by multiplying its rooms; nor is a country made better governed by multiplying its administrative boundaries.

Story Author
Other Related Stories
Top News
National