The Federal Constitutional Court ruled that unexercised federal powers cannot be assumed by provinces, reaffirming federal jurisdiction over certain matters.
ISLAMABAD, Nov. 21 (Lord Media): The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) has ruled that parliament’s failure to exercise a fiscal power does not transfer that authority to the provinces, reaffirming the federal legislature’s exclusive jurisdiction over certain matters, including imports, exports and interprovincial trade.
“An identified conflict with a competent federal law attracts the consequence prescribed under Article 142 of the Constitution, meaning that the federal law will prevail whereas the provincial law becomes void to the extent of that conflict,” Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan observed in a 59-page judgment authored by him.
The ruling came as a two-member FCC bench, comprising the chief justice and Justice Aamer Farooq, issued its detailed judgment on 568 challenges filed by taxpayers against infrastructure development cess imposed by Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.
The court allowed the taxpayers’ civil appeals, set aside the challenged judgments of the Sindh High Court and Peshawar High Court, and declared the relevant charging provisions, along with dependent rules, notifications, assessments and recovery measures, unconstitutional and without lawful authority.
“No demand, surcharge or penalty founded solely upon those charges shall be enforced,” the judgment stated. It added that securities furnished exclusively against the invalid charges would be released after verification, subject to any existing court order governing their disposal.
The FCC, however, said provincial governments remained free to impose constitutionally valid infrastructure or service charges on goods manufactured and consumed within their respective territories.
The judgment clarified that Article 160 of the Constitution and the applicable National Finance Commission arrangements distinguish between the authority to impose a federal tax and the right to receive a share of its proceeds.
A province’s entitlement to a share of federal tax revenue does not authorize it to impose that tax independently, the court observed. It added that the constitutional defect in the cases was a lack of legislative competence rather than duplication of taxation.
The FCC said the high courts had given decisive weight to the infrastructure purpose of the levies, the movement of goods and their claimed compensatory nature without first establishing whether the provinces had the constitutional authority to impose them.
None of those considerations independently empowered the provinces to impose charges on imports, exports and external transit, it ruled.
The court also observed that the abolition of the Concurrent Legislative List through the 18th Amendment had expanded provincial legislative authority but had not transferred matters expressly reserved for the federal government.
Provincial autonomy must be fully respected within its constitutional sphere while parliament retains exclusive authority over subjects assigned to the federal domain, the judgment said.
During the proceedings, the taxpayers had argued that the levies encroached upon parliament’s exclusive legislative jurisdiction and could not be justified as fees or compensatory charges merely because goods used provincial infrastructure.
They had also challenged the collection mechanisms, alleged discriminatory treatment, restrictions on trade and retrospective validation of the levies.
The provinces, meanwhile, had relied on their residual legislative powers, infrastructure responsibilities and services provided to commercial users, arguing that the cess was distinct from customs duties. LORD





















